5 Issues You Need to Know About Cultural Fit

Where Do YOU Fit In?

While searching for your dream career, you’ve probably come across the term “cultural fit” multiple times in job specs. It refers to how well a candidate’s values, beliefs and behaviours align with the company’s culture.

Generally, cultural fit is considered an important aspect for both employers and candidates because a strong cultural alignment can lead to higher job satisfaction, increased employee engagement and better overall performance.

On the other hand, there are potential downsides to this concept, which can hamper your chances of getting hired, plus hinder diversity and inclusion efforts within a workplace.

One Cultural Size Doesn’t Fit All

Here are five of those potential concerns about cultural fit that you need to be aware of:

1. Overemphasis on Uniformity

Focusing too much on cultural fit can lead to a lack of diversity within the company or business. This is a result of employers seeking candidates who exhibit the same existing values and behaviours of the team.

This results in personal creativity and innovation being stifled, which in turn can give rise to unproductivity, regression and frustration.

2. Bias and Discrimination

Imagine that you’ve just graduated from a tertiary institution that’s not exactly prominent but still has a solid academic reputation. As for personal background, you hail from a low-income family who emigrated from another country.

So, when applying for a job, you find yourself at a disadvantage, because the hiring team favours candidates whose experiences or backgrounds are similar to theirs, while they differ greatly from yours (eg. they might have attended the same prestigious university and/or lived in similar high-income neighbourhoods).

As you can see, an emphasis on cultural fit can unintentionally introduce biases into the hiring process. This can limit opportunities for under-represented groups.

3. Overlooking Skills and Experience

Oftentimes, candidates who possess the necessary skills, qualifications and experiences may be overlooked simply because they do not fit the company culture.

For example, even if you are a qualified data analyst who is skilled at statistical programming and adept at giving presentations, the employer might pass you over because your personality, approach or working methods differ from the existing team dynamics.

4. High Potential for Groupthink

A tight focus on cultural fit can lead to “groupthink”. This is where employees prioritise consensus and conformity in lieu of critical thinking and open dialogue.

Consider the following scenario: you are a junior product developer, and you’ve just joined a team of senior product developers who have been working on a new project for several months. They’ve established a routine and are comfortable with the dynamic they’ve created among themselves.

However, whenever you offer up a solution – such as using new software to replace the outdated software that is being used to develop the product – your team members are quick to dismiss any discussions about the solution’s merits or drawbacks. They retreat into their comfort zone, more stubborn than ever to change their rigid mindset.

Evidently, groupthink can hinder innovation, problem-solving and effective communication as employees become less willing to explore alternative viewpoints.

5. Retention Issues

If the cultural fit is misinterpreted or overly relied upon in hiring decisions, it may lead to dissatisfaction among employees who feel pressured to conform to a specific culture. This could foster an environment where individuals feel they cannot fully express themselves, resulting in higher turnover rates.

For example, your work performance is outstanding and you consistently deliver excellent results. However, the lack of openness from your team leads you to feel undervalued and unfulfilled. Despite your eagerness to contribute fresh ideas and innovative solutions, you find yourself stifled in an environment that prioritises conformity over creativity.

This can lead to increased frustration, which – if it isn’t addressed – can ultimately drive you to seek employment elsewhere.

Fighting Fit

There are three main solutions that can be put in place by employers to address the concerns surrounding cultural fit in hiring and workplace dynamics:

1. Emphasis on Diversity

It’s important for employers to promote diversity by valuing different perspectives, backgrounds and experiences. This can be achieved through broadening job descriptions, improving hiring practices by making them more inclusive, and focusing on values such as teamwork, creativity and problem-solving instead of specific cultural traits.

2. Restructure the Interview Process

Utilising an objective approach is needed to ensure that the interview process is fair and focused on candidates’ capabilities rather than their cultural fit. To do this, it will require asking candidates standardised interview questions that evaluate relevant skills and experiences, as well as giving them task-based assessments to gauge their abilities.

3. Foster an Inclusive Workplace Culture

To prevent retention issues, employers should work towards creating an inclusive culture that allows all employees to thrive. Steps to achieve this include encouraging open dialogue; creating safe spaces for employees to express differing opinions and ideas; and actively conducting regular surveys and gathering feedback from employees on the workplace culture.

Let’s Fit Together!

At the end of the day, it’s essential for both job-seekers and employers to strike a balance between maintaining a cohesive team dynamic and fostering an inclusive environment. Embracing unique perspectives not only enriches company culture, but also propels innovation, ultimately leading to a more successful workplace!

Image Credit: Source